By
Cherlynn Low, LAPTOP Staff Writer
|
Mar 7, 2014 04:35 PM EDT
When it comes to Web browsing on your Windows 8 tablet, chances are
you’ve already picked your favorite browser for the job. But you might
be missing out. The best browsers can enhance your surfing experience
with fast speeds, comprehensive standards support and intuitive
navigation. We put the three leading browsers for Windows 8′s “Metro”
mode — Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox and Internet Explorer — to the
test to see which one will serve you best.
Round 1: Interface (30 points)
From button placement to changing tabs, your browser’s layout is
fundamental to how quickly and comfortably you can surf the Web.
Chrome for Windows 8′s Metro mode simulates a Chrome OS desktop, with
the familiar browser layout open as a window accompanied by app icons
for Gmail, Google search, Docs and YouTube in a taskbar at the bottom.
Apart from the surrounding desktop, Google’s browser for Metro mode is
no different from its desktop version, with navigation icons and the URL
bar positioned at the top.
MORE: 10 Must-Have Apps for 2014
Both Internet Explorer and Firefox in Metro mode place the navigation
panel at the bottom for easier access with your thumbs. Internet
Explorer’s navigation panel is somewhat cluttered, with buttons for
Back, Refresh, Tabs, Favorites and Settings sitting along a URL and
search bar. Firefox employs a cleaner approach, with just Back,
Favorites, Pin and Options buttons next to its Awesome Bar (URL and
Search field).
These bottom panels in both Firefox and Internet Explorer auto-hide
so you can enjoy full-screen viewing. However, Firefox goes a step
further to make things easier and prettier by overlaying translucent
Back and New Tab buttons on the left and right of the screen so you
don’t have to leave a full screen just to open a new tab.
All three browsers support swiping left and right to move through back and forward through visited pages.
Internet Explorer and Firefox both helpfully suggest sites you might
be looking for as you enter a URL or keyword in the address bar, and
these results are tiled just above the field so you can easily tap them.
But when it comes to scrolling through the tabs you have open, Internet
Explorer has the edge, displaying them just above the address bar when
you hit Tabs while Firefox docks them at the top of the screen.
Each time you open a new tab, Firefox displays a pretty speed dial of
your recent, most visited pages and your most frequented bookmarks so
you don’t have to waste time typing URLs. Internet Explorer suggests
frequent sites, but only within a black panel above the keyboard, which
affords it less space.
When it comes to switching between Desktop and Metro modes, Firefox
offers the most seamless transition. You can easily re-launch the
browser in your preferred format by tapping the Options button next to
the Awesome Bar, and your open tabs are preserved whenever you switch.
Chrome provides easy access to the re-launch tool, but its tiny
interface makes the option hard to find, and neither browser maintains
your open tabs. Internet Explorer maintains two different and unrelated
browsers at the same time, one for desktop and one for Metro.
Winner: Firefox. We love the simple navigation panel, the helpful new tab page and the seamless switching between desktop and Metro modes.
Round 2: Speed (30 points)
Though the performance of your Web connection and your CPU do more to
determine your overall surfing speed, your browser also has a role to
play.
Using the Numion website loading stopwatch tool, we measured how long
it took each browser to load NYTimes.com and Laptopmag.com. Between
each round of tests, carried out on the same Windows 8.1 tablet (Acer
Iconia W4) over the same Wi-Fi connection, we cleared the cache for each
browser.
Across all the different pages, Firefox consistently emerged as the
speediest browser. It fully loaded NYTimes.com and Laptopmag.com in an
average of 3.21 seconds and 4.85 seconds, respectively. Internet
Explorer came in second overall, pushing the same sites through in an
average of 4.17 seconds and 5.41 seconds. Chrome brought up the rear,
displaying NYTimes.com and Laptopmag.com in 5.06 seconds and 6.94
seconds.
Firefox also proved fastest in the SunSpider JavaScript speed test.
Scoring 573.6 milliseconds on average, the open-source browser just
barely beat Internet Explorer (576.8 ms average) and Chrome (598.6 ms
average).
Chrome took the lead in HTML5 loading speeds, however, beating the
others on Peacekeeper with its score of 1,156. Firefox followed with
879, while Internet Explorer delivered a poorer 672.
MORE: Top 25 Windows 8 Apps
On more taxing tasks, such as rendering a complex WebGL (Web Graphics
Language) environment, Firefox lost its lead to Chrome. While Firefox
maintained 45 fps with 50 fish and 41 fps with 100 fish in the tank
simulation (Chrome got 40 / 39 fps), Google’s browser pulled ahead when
250 fish were thrown in the mix, providing 37 fps against Firefox’s 32
fps. Internet Explorer delivered a poorer 43 fps at 50 fish, 39 fps at
100 fps and a weak 29 fps with 250 fish.
While Chrome delivered better Peacekeeper scores, the app’s
performance was unfortunately clunky and glitchy during our testing.
This means that while HTML5-heavy pages may load faster on Chrome,
you’ll spend so much time trying to open tabs because the overall
experience is frustratingly slow.
Winner: Firefox. Blazing page loading speeds and overall faster performance makes this app the Flash of the browser world.
Round 3: Special Features (20 points)
Since Chrome for Windows 8 is basically the desktop version of the
browser bundled with Google’s OS, you get access to a world of more than
30,000 apps, extensions and add-ons that make your browser more
feature-rich. You also get tab indicators to show you, at a glance,
which of your pages is making noise or playing a video.
Given the mobile environment, though, the usefulness of these
features is questionable. Each Chrome tab is tiny on an 8-inch tablet’s
screen, and the indicator symbols become minuscule and hard to see. (The
experience on larger screens is more comfortable.) You’re also less
likely to use a Chrome Web app such as Pixlr Photo Editor when you can
use Photoshop Express and other full-fledged programs on your device.
Both Internet Explorer and Firefox offer useful special features,
such as Do Not Track to signal to servers not to record your presence.
While all three browsers can be used in Windows 8.1′s split screen mode,
only Internet Explorer can be docked side by side with another window
of itself. This is especially useful for times when you want to compare
two different cinema listings, for example. You can’t do this with
Chrome or Firefox.
Internet Explorer, not surprisingly, boasts comprehensive native
integration. You can pin specific sites to your Start screen as a Live
Tile to get notifications when the Web page is updated, split the
display between up to four windows for side-by-side browsing and easily
call numbers on websites with Skype Click to Call. A built-in Reading
List app lets you save pages and read them when you have time later.
Microsoft’s browser also boasts a Flip ahead feature that lets you
scroll through parts of a multi-page article by swiping from the right
side of the screen to go to the next page.
MORE: 8 Worst Windows 8 Annoyances and How to Fix Them
Internet Explorer 11 comes with Adobe Flash installed out-of-the-box
so you don’t have to go through the troublesome process of loading the
plug-in for yourself. The browser can also detect your gyroscope so you
can use websites that make use of the hardware just like an app.
However, few sites actually use this feature.
Winner: Internet Explorer. It’s no surprise that the
default browser comes packed with excellent device integration, and we
especially like being able to view two websites side by side.
Round 4: Standards Support (15 points)
The extent to which a browser supports various Web standards can
greatly impact how much you enjoy your favorite sites. A good browser
should be able to interpret and display most Web languages or plug-ins
such as HTML5, CSS3 and JavaScript so that you can experience a page the
way a developer intended.
We put all three browsers through a series of tests to see how well they supported common Web standards.
Chrome stood out when it came to HTML5 support, scoring 505 out of
555 on the HTML5test.com benchmark. This test checks to see if your
browser is capable of displaying common HTML5 features, such as
drag-and-drop, graphics rendering, geolocation and device orientation.
Firefox came in second with 458, while Internet Explorer delivered a
mere 372. Internet Explorer also met just five of seven HTML5
capabilities on the Peacekeeper test where Firefox and Chrome both met
all seven.
MORE: 8 Essential Tips for Your New Windows 8 PC
Chrome also did well on CSS3 support, scoring 60 percent on the CSS3
test and beating Firefox (58 percent) and Internet Explorer (53
percent).
Thanks to its support of the Lazyload tag, Internet Explorer 11 can
also let developers lower the priority of an item, keeping unwanted
items like ads from clogging up bandwidth while you load a site.
Winner: Chrome. Google’s browser better supports common Web standards, with Firefox coming in a close second.
Round 5: Syncability (15 points)
Often, you want to move from your mobile device to your desktop for a
fuller reading experience, but transferring your many open tabs can be
troublesome. Thankfully, all three browsers let you sync your content
across devices so you won’t have to manually hunt down the specific site
you were reading. Some browsers do this better, bookmarking your last
position on the page so you can pick up right where you left off.
With Chrome, simply sign into your Google account to pull your open
tabs across various linked devices. You can choose to open pages by
clicking Recent Tabs under the Options button, which saves not only
pages that are open on connected systems but also a full browsing
history of the past four months. You can also search this log, arranged
in chronological order, so hunting for that one page you visited that
one time about an obscure topic is easy.
Firefox Sync’s setup process is somewhat tedious. You’ll have to sign
in to your Firefox account via the browser in the desktop environment.
The browser generates three sets of short codes, which you’ll have to
enter into the device you want to link to your account. Getting to the
page to input these codes takes quite a few steps, which is troublesome.
Once you’ve gone through the setup process, Firefox lets you sync
your add-ons, bookmarks, history, tabs and preferences, and save
passwords. It’s a nifty feature since you won’t have to retype passwords
into pages you’ve already signed into – Firefox Sync remembers and
fills those fields in for you. Unfortunately, you won’t be able to sync
your open tabs. The feature also doesn’t work properly if you have beta
and production versions of Firefox installed on the same device.
You can only sync content on Internet Explorer across Windows 8.1
devices, which limits the usefulness of this feature. It’s also tedious
to set up; you’ll need to enable Web Browser in Sync Settings in each of
your Windows 8.1 devices after you’ve signed into them. We would prefer
being able to sign into and pull open tabs and preferences directly
from Internet Explorer itself rather than having to dig into the pits of
Microsoft’s settings.
Once your devices are set up, though, the interface for IE is fairly
simple. Just click the drop-down arrow next to Tabs when you open a new
tab and you can open any page from your connected devices.
Winner: Chrome. A simple sign-in process without the
need to create a separate account if you already are a user of Google’s
other services gives Chrome the edge. A comprehensive backlog of
visited pages is another plus.
Verdict
Speedy load times, a clean interface and good support for standards
make Firefox our top browser for Windows 8.1′s Modern environment. While
Chrome has better support for Web standards and simpler syncing
capabilities, it desperately needs a touch-optimized interface. Also,
throughout our testing, Chrome was by far the glitchiest browser, often
crashing or refusing to register our touch.
Like Firefox, Internet Explorer has a touch-friendly interface and it
adds the advantage of being able to launch more than one Metro window,
but slower speeds, worse standards support and a completely separate
desktop browser hold it back. Bottom line: You can’t go wrong with
Mozilla’s browser for your Windows 8.1 device.
Source:
http://blog.laptopmag.com/best-windows-8-browser